Lithium iron phosphate batteries(LFP) and ternary lithium batteries (NMC) are the protagonists in the new energy field in recent years. These two types of batteries have excellent safety performance and energy density, so they are widely used in electric vehicles, electric motorcycles, energy storage and other fields.
What is the difference between lfp vs nmc battery? Which battery will dominate the future market? This article will introduce the working principle, cycle life, energy density, charging strategy and other contents of lfp vs nmc battery in detail to increase users’ understanding of these two batteries.
LFP vs NMC battery: chemical composition and working principle
NMC battery: uses nickel cobalt manganese (NCM) or nickel cobalt aluminum (NCA) alloy as the cathode material, and graphite is commonly used as the anode. It stores and releases electrical energy through the migration of lithium ions between the cathode and anode. It contains highly active metal elements and has a higher energy density.
LFP battery: uses iron phosphate as the cathode material and graphite as the anode. Its working principle is similar to that of ternary lithium battery. However, lithium iron phosphate batteries have stronger chemical stability and perform smoothly during charging and discharging.
LFP vs NMC battery: comparison of main differences
Different materials
lfp vs nmc battery are different types of lithium batteries. The anode is graphite, but the cathode material is different. Therefore, the cathode material is usually used to distinguish lithium batteries. Lithium iron phosphate battery refers to a lithium-ion battery that uses lithium iron phosphate as the cathode material, while ternary lithium battery refers to a lithium-ion battery that uses nickel cobalt manganese oxide as the cathode material.
Since lithium iron phosphate batteries do not contain precious metal elements such as cobalt, their raw material prices are also lower, and the resources of phosphorus and iron on the earth are also relatively abundant. On the contrary, ternary lithium batteries not only have higher raw material costs, but also higher production technology barriers.
Different energy density
In terms of energy density, lithium iron phosphate batteries and ternary lithium batteries are also different. The energy density of lithium iron phosphate battery cells is about 110Wh/kg, while the energy density of ternary lithium battery cells is about 200Wh/kg.
Therefore, for the same weight of lfp vs nmc battery, the energy density of ternary lithium battery is 1.6-1.7 times that of lithium iron phosphate battery, and ternary lithium battery can bring longer battery life to electric vehicles.
Temperature performance differences
In terms of temperature resistance, lithium iron phosphate batteries and ternary lithium batteries also have different performances. Under high temperature conditions, ternary lithium batteries will decompose at 200°C, while the decomposition temperature of lithium phosphate batteries is 800°C. Therefore, lithium iron phosphate batteries are more resistant to high temperatures and less likely to catch fire, which also indirectly shows that lithium iron phosphate batteries are safer.
However, although lithium iron phosphate batteries are resistant to high temperatures, they perform poorly under low temperature conditions, and their maximum operating temperature is around minus 20 degrees. The maximum temperature of ternary lithium batteries is around minus 30 degrees, so electric vehicles equipped with ternary lithium batteries will perform better under low temperature conditions.
Different charge and discharge cycle life
In terms of charge and discharge times, the two also have different performances. Among them, the charge and discharge cycle times of lithium iron phosphate batteries can reach 3500-5000 times, while the cycle times of ternary lithium batteries are only about 2500 times. In other words, electric vehicles equipped with lithium iron phosphate batteries can be used for a longer time.
From the above comparison, it can be seen that lfp vs nmc battery have their own advantages and disadvantages. Among them, lithium iron phosphate batteries have the advantages of high temperature resistance, strong safety and stability, low price, and better cycle performance; while ternary lithium batteries are more resistant to low temperatures, have higher capacity density, and of course their prices are also higher.
LFP vs NMC battery: charging strategy comparison
The reason why NMC batteries are not recommended to be fully charged
Lithium dendrite growth: With the charge and discharge cycle, high-nickel ternary lithium batteries in a fully charged state are prone to lithium dendrite growth. Lithium dendrites may pierce the battery separator, causing internal short circuits, and then cause safety problems such as thermal runaway, such as battery fires and explosions, which seriously threaten the safety of vehicles and personnel.
Increased side reactions: When fully charged, the internal chemical reaction activity of ternary lithium batteries is high, and side reactions are prone to occur in harsh environments such as high temperatures, further reducing battery safety. Moreover, when a fully charged ternary lithium battery encounters physical damage such as external collisions and extrusions, or is used for a long time in a high temperature environment, the risk of thermal runaway is relatively high; when overcharging occurs, safety problems are more likely to occur. Overcharging will cause the internal voltage of the battery to be too high and the temperature to rise sharply, increasing the risk of thermal runaway.
Damage to electrode materials: Frequently fully charging and keeping the ternary lithium battery at full charge will cause the electrode material inside the battery to be under great pressure. This will gradually damage the structure of the electrode material, accelerate the capacity decay of the battery, and reduce the available capacity and cycle life of the battery.
Accelerate the aging process: Frequently fully charging the ternary lithium battery will cause it to undergo more charge and discharge cycles at high voltage, which will also accelerate the aging process of the battery and reduce its service life.
Reasons why LFP batteries need to be fully charged regularly
Avoid false capacity loss: If lithium iron phosphate batteries are often not fully charged during long-term use, the battery management system (BMS) may miscalculate the available capacity of the battery based on the charge and discharge history, resulting in “false battery capacity loss”. Regular full charging can help the BMS recalibrate the battery capacity to avoid capacity loss caused by long-term undercharging.
Ensure accurate judgment of the BMS: The BMS of some lithium iron phosphate batteries needs to accurately judge and calibrate the battery status through the voltage and current data in the fully charged state. Long-term undercharging may affect the normal operation of the BMS, thereby reducing the performance and life of the battery.
Activate chemical reactions: For some lithium iron phosphate battery systems that use specific battery management strategies, regular full charging can activate some chemical reactions inside the battery, which helps maintain the state of the battery’s active substances and thus extend the battery’s service life.
Stabilize electrode structure: A proper full charge state can keep the electrode material of the lithium iron phosphate battery in a relatively stable structural state, reducing electrode material aging and capacity decay that may be caused by long-term partial charging.
Other aspects: The positive electrode material of the lithium iron phosphate battery is lithium iron phosphate, which has a relatively stable crystal structure. It is not easy to have safety problems such as lithium dendrite growth when fully charged, and it is relatively safe. In addition, its charging and discharging platform is relatively flat, and the battery voltage changes relatively little during charging. Full charging will not have much negative impact on the structure and performance of the battery.
According to the above content, it can be seen that the charging strategies of lfp vs nmc battery are different. Therefore, in the application, the charging methods of the two batteries should be paid attention to, and the correct charging should be done to extend the battery life.
Which type of battery is the future development direction?
Lithium iron phosphate batteries and ternary lithium batteries have their own advantages and disadvantages, so which one is the future development direction? In fact, everyone has different opinions on this issue. However, BYD and CATL have given the answer with practical actions. Lithium iron phosphate batteries are the future of new energy vehicles.
Since BYD launched the lithium iron phosphate blade battery in 2020, the disadvantage of its energy density being inferior to that of ternary lithium batteries has been greatly weakened. At the same time, due to BYD’s breakthrough in battery technology, the range of pure electric vehicles equipped with lithium iron phosphate batteries can reach more than 600 kilometers. And BYD has also proved the success of lithium iron phosphate batteries with the performance of 3 million electric vehicles.
In addition, as a global power battery giant, although CATL’s early power battery route was ternary lithium batteries, due to the rising prices of battery raw materials such as cobalt and nickel, CATL had to find another way out, so lithium iron phosphate batteries became the first choice, and maintained the parallel development of ternary lithium batteries and lithium iron phosphate batteries.
Tesla Model 3 and Model Y are both equipped with lithium iron phosphate batteries provided by CATL. Thanks to the decline in battery costs, these two models have been reduced in price many times in China. Recently, Tesla announced a price reduction again, with the highest reduction of Model Y reaching 48,000. In addition, BMW, Ford, Hyundai, Renault and other automakers have said that they will consider switching to lithium iron phosphate batteries with cost-effective advantages.
As battery subsidies decline, automakers are more determined to choose lithium iron phosphate batteries. China’s electric vehicle subsidies will be phased out in 2023, so the advantage of ternary lithium batteries in obtaining policy subsidies due to their higher energy density will be weakened. In the next few years, the demand for lithium iron phosphate batteries from major automakers will gradually increase, making the growth rate of lithium iron phosphate battery production far exceed that of ternary lithium batteries.
Conclusion
The above is a comparative analysis of LFP vs NMC battery. In addition to the lithium iron phosphate battery and ternary lithium battery that currently dominate the market, new battery technology routes such as lithium iron manganese phosphate, solid-state battery, lithium-rich manganese-based battery, and sodium-ion battery have also attracted the attention of many car companies.
In the future, with the continuous improvement of battery technology, these new battery technology routes will soon be put into use. At that time, the new energy market may not be a matter of choosing between lithium iron phosphate batteries and ternary lithium batteries.















